Wed 12 Nov 2008
BREAKING NEWS: Saturday Night Live “not as funny as it used to be”
Posted by MarkFore under politics , pop culture , televisionI would like to parody those who make the blanket statement that Saturday Night Live is not like it used to be but I’ll leave that up to The Onion, since they dabble in that forum.
But to quote Seth Meyers and Amy Poehler (they’re both on SNL), “Really??” Saturday Night Live is no longer funny? “Really??” Don’t you miss the multi-faceted comedic stylings of Molly Shannon? Or David Spade? I really wish they would bring Colin Quinn back to do “Weekend Update”. Every person has some opinion on what era of Saturday Night Live was funny. Mark Wahlberg likes the Joe Piscopo era.
I’ve been wanting to bring this up for a while but haven’t been cranky enough. Recently Saturday Night Live got more attention with the election coverage and SNL has always had a history of doing a lot of election related stuff. That’s great because it probably keeps SNL in the ratings enough to keep going.
Unfortunately, this was mostly because of a spot on impression of Palin by Tina Fey. I imagine most of the people who followed it, a demographic that included my parents, don’t even realize Tina Fey is not in the cast. Mark Wahlberg couldn’t name anybody on the show and a few weeks later he was on the show. Now I’m not saying it’s your civic duty to watch and appreciate SNL. I guess I’m just airing out the fact that it’s still a very funny and relevant show. It has its moments but it definitely has a more solid cast and writers than any of the ones I grew up with. So don’t act appalled when I mention watching SNL this weekend or I ask you if you saw it.
I thought the Palin impressions and political coverage were cute but pretty predictable and standard. Some of the funnier, more poignant moments came when Tina Fey read back word for word what Sarah Palin actually said in an interview. That’s funny and gets the point across but definitely doesn’t show the abilities of the warped minds of the cast. Even something as timely as a rip on MacGyver or the Match Game ends up turning into a Twilight Zone-meets-comedy maze but with the ability to stop after 5 minutes, if they’re going nowhere. There are few if any weak links on the cast now and even Kenan is funny now, “Bokay?”
As Ransom says, “the things I laugh at anymore are either fart jokes or ones that make me say, ‘O ho ho ho, that was quite a marvelous turn that took.’” I’m glad SNL is able to combine both for me without turning in to an impression-riddled TV version of Scary Movie 5 or Date Movie 2 where they rehash word for word something that wasn’t funny the first time around. But really, I’m an elitist that is just glad to see that some shows still exist that aren’t racing for the bottom. Two and a Half Men is one of the highest rated shows on TV.
November 12th, 2008 at 11:31 pm
I totally agree on this issue (you know this). I get really inappropriately angry when people start going off on how Saturday Night Live is never funny, and then I ask them how often they watch it, and they’re like, um, Jimmy Fallon is still on, right? That guy sucks! I really like SNL and I hate when people dis on it just because that’s the received wisdom. I guess this comment is not really going anywhere. I just wanted to say my feelings on this issue.
November 17th, 2008 at 12:41 pm
Your Onion link hit the nail on the head, and I still regularly watch the show. Mind you, I employ a crutch, since I bang out the 90 minutes on Sunday with Tivo or when I used my VCR. The show’s consistency is sinusoidal, rather than a consistent decline. If you don’t want to take the time to catch episodes by any means, you will probably still watch any sketch that reaches meme status.
I also hypothesize that people’s SNL tastes run parallel to their music tastes. Some folks will stick with what they grew up listening to or watching, while others will consistently glom on to new material. Of course, you are the template for this theory.
November 17th, 2008 at 1:11 pm
SNL has always gone through its ups and downs. Very rarely will you get an entire episode that is perfect. The show has always had bright spots (and i’ve been watching since I thought Church Lady was a real woman).
I think the most important thing to recognize is that the writing is getting a lot smarter and is able to tackle a larger range of humor than ever before.
And what about the musical guests, they’ve gotten 923084938 times better!